Often when Jim and Greg discuss RIAA lawsuits in the news, the stories seem to paint a dreary picture for the average music fan. But this week things are looking up for the little guy. Last year Jammie Thomas was convicted of music piracy in the country's first file-sharing trial. But, now the judge is asking for a new trial. U.S. District Judge Michael J. Davis believes he didn't instruct the jury properly and didn't insist that the prosecution prove files were actually downloaded. In addition, he thinks the $220,000 fine is completely excessive. The judge is also urging for better copyright laws, something Jim and Greg have been saying for years.
The consumer does not fare as well in the next news story. Both Wal-Mart and Yahoo! Music have announced that customers who purchased music with DRM protection will not be able access their purchases for much longer. In Yahoo's case, it is because their music store, and consequently their DRM server, is shutting down. And, while Wal-Mart was wise to eliminate DRM files, Jim and Greg don't understand why customers who purchased songs prior to this shift should penalized. For every step forward in the digital music industry, there are at least two steps back.
Jim and Greg next give their takes on the recent My Bloody Valentine reunion show. The influential U.K. band played Chicago as their first tour in 16 years, and both Jim and Greg were there to witness it, though one has to wonder if they saw the same show. Both critics agree that the band's 1991 album Loveless was a masterpiece, but Jim wished they had played some new material. He also didn't see evidence that the band has kept up with the times, calling their dated loops and samples cheesy. Greg was much more impressed and thinks the members of MBV deserve one free pass in terms of not having new material. He was also blown away by their sound - almost literally.
Next up Jim and Greg check into the "Psychedelic Shack" for a discussion of Psychedelic Soul music. One of the architects of the genre, Norman Whitfield, passed away recently, so Jim and Greg thought his sound warranted more discussion. As a songwriter and producer, Whitfield helped escort The Temptations from their Motown sound, to one that was much funkier and rock-inspired. As Greg explains Whitfield wanted to "out-Sly Sly." By Sly he is of course referring to Sly and the Family Stone, who along with Jimi Hendrix, are the pillars of the early Psychedelic Soul movement. For a full taste of the genre, Jim and Greg recommend checking out the following artists:
Sly and the Family Stone
De La Soul
After releasing a successful solo debut, Jenny Lewis is back with a new record called Acid Tongue. While the first album was something of an accident, this one is much more thought out, with a cast of famous helpers including Elvis Costello, Chris Robinson and She & Him. Jim could've done without some of their appearances, but loves this record "to pieces." He explains that Lewis tries out a variety of styles, but all the songs are linked by an emphasis on strong vocals and natural recording. Greg completely agrees. He is less sour than Jim on Lewis' other project, but thinks that on her own she's made another two much better albums. Acid Tongue gets two Buy Its.
Twenty-five years after releasing the original version of Berlin, Lou Reed is back with a live version, as well as a film recording. Back in 1973, the record was almost universally panned, but Jim and Greg both believe that it deserves a second look, and this live album is the perfect way to do it. Greg describes the songs as harrowing, but also beautiful. It's not an easy album to listen to, but Reed brings his old songs new empathy. He gives it a Buy It rating. Jim thinks fans are better off purchasing this album than the first one, especially when you consider that Berlin 1973 wasn't recorded very well. He also gives Berlin: Live at St. Ann’s Warehouse a Buy It.
- Journey, "Don't Stop Believing," Escape, CBS Records International, 1981
- The Eagles, "Business As Usual," Long Road Out of Eden, Lost Highway, 2007
- My Bloody Valentine, "Only Shallow," Loveless, High Fader, 1991
- The Temptations, "Ball of Confusion," Greatest Hits Volume 2, Gordy, 1970
- Jimi Hendrix, "Fire," Are You Experienced, Track, 1967
- Sly and the Family Stone, "I Want to Take You Higher," Stand!, Epic, 1969
- The Temptations, "Psychedelic Shack," Psychedelic Shack, Gordy, 1970
- Bill Cosby, "Hooray for the Salvation Army Band," Hooray for the Salvation Army Band!, Rhino/Warner Bros., 1968
- Funkadelic, "Maggot Brain," Maggot Brain, Westbound, 1971
- Funkadelic, "Wars of Armegeddon," Maggot Brain, Westbound, 1971
- Funkadelic, "Hit It and Quit It," Maggot Brain, Westbound, 1971
- The Isley Brothers, "That Lady (Part 1 & 2)," 3 + 3, T-Neck, 1973
- War, "Spill the Wine," The Best of War and More, Avenue, 1991
- Prince and The Revolution, "Rasberry Beret," Around the World in a Day, Warner Bros., 1985
- Dr. Octagon, "Blue Flowers," Dr. Octagonecologyst, Bulk, 1996
- Outkast, "B.O.B.," Stankonia, BMG Japan, 2000
- Gnarls Barkley, "Crazy," St. Elsewhere, Warner Music UK, 2006
- Jenny Lewis, "Acid Tongue," Acid Tongue, Rough Trade, 2008
- Jenny Lewis, "Jack Killed Mom," Acid Tongue, Rough Trade, 2008
- Jenny Lewis, "Black Sand," Acid Tongue, Rough Trade, 2008
- Lou Reed, "How Do You Think It Feels," Berlin: Live at St. Ann's Warehouse, Matador, 2008
- Lou Reed, "Sad Song," Berlin: Live at St. Ann's Warehouse, Matador, 2008
- I Am Robot And Proud, "Island Life," Uphill City, & Records, 2008
- Dengue Fever, "Tiger Phone Card," Venus on Earth, M80, 2008
- Joan As Police Woman, "Hard White Wall," To Survive, Reveal, 2008
- Metallica, "Battery," Master of Puppets, Elektra, 1986
For more than 15 years, Sound Opinions was a production of WBEZ, Chicago's public radio station. Now that the show is independent, we're inviting you to join the band and lend a hand! We need your support more than ever because now we have to do all the behind-the-scenes work that WBEZ handled before (like buying insurance and paying for podcast hosting, ugh). Plus, we have some exciting ideas we'd like to try now that there's no one to tell us no!